Frank Malzone's walk-off single in the 12th inning,
earns the Sox a split with the Indians

May 4, 1958 ... There was never a more satisfying pitching duel, than the one that took place at Fenway when young Frank Baumann bested the veteran Hoyt Wilhem, in a 12 inning battle that Baumann won, to give his Sox a split of a doubleheader.

One bad pitch by the young fire-baller cost him a shutout. A well-stroked homer by the Indians' Preston Ward, forced him to pitch three extra innings and get the 2 to 1 win.

Baumann had a chance to win the game himself in the ninth inning. With the game knotted at 1-1, he opened the inning with a double to left-center and was bunted to third by Don Buddin. Pete Runnels then hit a dribbler between the mound and third base. Baumann started home and then went back.

Into the 12th inning the game went and Gene Stephens legged out a drag bunt to lead off. Billy Consolo forced him at second and went to second on a wild pitch from Indians' reliever Steve Ridzik, while Jackie Jensen watched at the plate. Jensen was then given an intentional pass, and Frank Malzone lined a single, bringing Consolo home with the game winning run, 2-1.

In the first game, Tom Brewer went the distance, leading 1-0 going into the eighth inning. But Minnie Minoso started the eighth with a base hit and scored the tying run when Rocky Colavito doubled off the wall and moved to third on a ground out. Then the Indians tried to squeeze in the go-ahead run. Russ Nixon missed on an attempt to bunt and Sammy White tagged out the charging Colavito at the plate.

The Sox made a bid to win in the ninth inning. Malzone singled off relief pitcher, Mike Garcia, who then hit White with a pitch.  In came Ridzik, who walked Jimmy Piersall and Jensen was the called on to pinch hit for Brewer but was called out on strikes, to end the threat. The Indians went on to win in the ninth, 2 to 1, on a single and a double by Bobby Avila.

 

BILLY CONSOLO SLIDES HOME WITH THE WINNING RUN

 

 

F   E   N   W   A   Y     P   A   R   K

 

Game #1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

 

R

H

E

 
 

CLEVELAND INDIANS

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

1

1

 

 

2

9

0

 
 

BOSTON RED SOX

0

0

0

1

0

0

0

0

0

 

 

1

6

0

 

 

W-Mike Garcia (1-0)
S-Don Ferrarese (1)
L-Tom Brewer (1-3)
Attendance: 23,029

 2B-Colavito (Clev), Avila (Clev)

 

 

F   E   N   W   A   Y     P   A   R   K

 

Game #2

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

 

R

H

E

 
 

CLEVELAND INDIANS

0

0

0

0

1

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

 

1

8

0

 
 

BOSTON RED SOX

0

0

0

1

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

1

 

2

12

1

 

 

W-Frank Baumann (1-1)
L-Steve Ridzik (0-3)

 2B-Gernert (Bost), Baumann (Bost), Malzone (Bost)

 HR-Ward (Clev)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Game #1

AB

R

H

AVG

 

 

Don Buddin ss 4 0 1 .278  

 

Pete Runnels 2b 4 0 0 .359  

 

Ted Williams lf 3 1 2 .214  

 

Dick Gernert 1b 3 0 0 .250  

 

Gene Stephens rf 3 0 0 .172  

 

Frank Malzone 3b 4 0 2 .250  

 

Sammy White c 3 0 0 .286  

 

Billy Consolo pr 0 0 0 .133  

 

Jimmy Piersall cf 3 0 1 .214  

 

Tom Brewer p 3 0 0 .125  

 

Billy Klaus ph 0 0 0 .167  

 

Jackie Jensen ph 1 0 0 .192  

 

    IP H ER BB SO  

 

Tom Brewer 9 9 2 5 4  

 

 

         

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Game #2

AB

R

H

AVG

 

 

Don Buddin ss 5 0 2 .288  

 

Pete Runnels 2b/1b 6 0 0 .329  

 

Gene Stephens lf 6 1 2 .200  

 

Dick Gernert 1b 4 0 2 .292  

 

Billy Consolo pr/2b 2 1 0 .125  

 

Jackie Jensen rf 4 0 1 .196  

 

Frank Malzone 3b 5 0 3 .274  

 

Lou Berberet c 2 0 0 .125  

 

Jimmy Piersall cf 5 0 1 .213  

 

Frank Baumann p 4 0 1 .167  

 

    IP H ER BB SO  

 

Frank Baumann 12 8 1 4 5  

 

 

         

 

 

 

1958 AMERICAN LEAGUE STANDINGS

 

 

New York Yankees 10 4 -

 

 

Washington Senators 9 5 1

 

 

Kansas City Athletics 8 7 2 1/2

 

 

Cleveland Indians 10 9 2 1/2

 

 

Baltimore Orioles 8 8 3

 

 

Detroit Tigers 8 10 4

 

 

BOSTON RED SOX 7 11 5

 

 

Chicago White Sox 4 10 6